While playing through the latest offering from I couldn't shake the Carlsberg advert slogan from my mind. If Nintendo made an game 'it would probably be' the best Indiana Jones game in the world. I reference Indiana Jones deliberately as it is not only a great adventure film, but it can be pretty much enjoyed by all ages. The trouble is Nintendo do not make games like Indiana Jones. They make games like Zelda. It is a game that combines technical brilliance with artistic flair but I'm afraid because of its childlike story telling I found it somewhat un-engaging.

Before I start talking about the bad let me first tell you about the good, because there is an awful lot to admire in this game. Obviously the first element that leaps to mind is the graphics on offer, namely Nintendo's use of cell shading. Screen shots can't really do justice to the effect; it is in the lighting and animation that this technique truly shines. Subtle touches like the heat distortion from torches give the game a very rich and vibrant look. Even the theme of the title, wind, is rendered to good effect. Think about it, how do you render wind? Well Nintendo have managed it. I found many of the designs reminiscent of Disney's Hercules, whose style resulted from collaborating with a British artist called Gerald Scarfe. While I don't care for the look of Link, the rest of the cast is interesting and diverse. From strange little tree people to an impressively large dragon, you will love the characters on show.

You'll meet these different characters as you journey from island to island amidst a 'waterworld' that comprises this adventure. Initially you start off on your own small home island, meeting and greeting the inhabitants. Each person there will have a little piece of advice for you regarding different parts of the game. It's a well thought out introduction and superbly implemented, allowing you to spend as much or as little time as you like learning the controls. At the outset you'll have no items to contend with but very soon you are given a sword and also trained in its use. As in the last Zelda offering, sword fighting forms the backbone of most of the combat and it is also very enjoyable, with a number of thrusts and parries at your disposal. Once you've got the hang of things you are drawn into a story that deals with the legend of Hyrule, Tri Force pieces, and all the other trappings of a Zelda game. You're not alone on this journey. You are given a boat to get from A to B, a boat that also happens to talk. From this point onward you sail across the ocean journeying to different islands, each of which will normally yield another item/weapon and another chapter in the story.

Comments

You can use BBCode

  1. chris Unregistered 6 years ago

    Zelda is about exploration. You really should have freed Tingle from his cell way back in the beginning before you even got your sail, especially if you wanted the camera.

  2. chris Unregistered 6 years ago

    "Still fun though, but vastly overrated"

    Agreed. Some people seem to think that just because it's Zelda it's great and that Nintendo can do no wrong. Don't get me wrong here, I'm a huge Nintendo fan, but I can accept the truth. As for searching for everything, it just doesn't feel as rewarding this time round. The sailing takes way too long and to get all the character models from the photographs would just take too long and it would bore the life out of me and it would become more of a chore than entertainment.

  3. CanadianLink Unregistered 6 years ago

    First off, I am a huge fan of Zelda and Nintendo and I was really looking foard to this game coming out. Then it was here and I was blown away by the graphics. Well after that wore off and I got pulled into the game, I was dissapointed to see the lack of difficulty and dungouns. I mean come on it gets boring after awhile trapsing around in your boat. And the bosses were nothing spectacular. With all the time they had to make this game they could have made it alot harder. Overall I was satisfied but the ending for those who have played the game and the 2 above things I have mentioned have left me with the feeling of being jiped and wanting more, but hey maybe they do that for a reason. Well later.

  4. Jason Unregistered 6 years ago

    What kind of comment is that?!??!

  5. Aussie boy {'S'} Unregistered 6 years ago

    This game is cool ! I reccomend this to any especially people who enjoyed the other zelda titles.

    I give it 10 out of 10

  6. windwaker lollypop Unregistered 6 years ago

    how many hearts are there in the whole game

  7. Vincentsangina Unregistered 6 years ago

    I really enjoyed playing this game. It plays like a dream and looks breathtaking at the same time. Also it doesn't rely on overlong video sequences to bulk out the story, you have to play to discover things. That's why its fun...to progress you have to put the effort in and work out the answers to the puzzles. But like a number of recent Nintendo offerings it was way too short. Perhaps thats why they bundled it with Ocarina of Time and the Master Quest.

  8. chris Unregistered 6 years ago

    The game is great, but not that great. It's far too short and it doesn't have that feeling of being able to explore unlike previous Zelda's. As for the bit about searching for TriForce shards, well all you had to do was visit Tingle on his island he gives you a map of all the locations. Simple. And if you didn't know to go to Tingles island then you're the worst Zelda player ever, he tells you to visit him when you need help.

  9. Metroid Fan Unregistered 6 years ago

    What's with you talking about Zelda saying it should be like Indiana Jones and that Nintendo should make that game instead? Hello, Zelda is a first-party game and Indiana Jones isn't. What is really sad is that you needed to go to gamefaqs to find all eight triforce pieces. No wonder you didn't enjoy the game, because you suck at it. If it felt to short for you or you thought it wasn't any good, I might recommend that you rent it first. Also, just because you beaten the game doesn't mean that you are done. You have to find all the items and heart pieces.

  10. julie Unregistered 6 years ago

    this site may rock your world

  11. Link Unregistered 5 years ago

    yeah right then try passing it if you can then lets see if it is a baby game uh!

  12. Link Unregistered 5 years ago

    I could help you if you exatly tell me where are you stuck on.

  13. Link Unregistered 5 years ago

    it is a better one than yours idiot!!!

  14. Link Unregistered 5 years ago

    I agree!

  15. Link Unregistered 5 years ago

    15

  16. creul.lollypop.bba 5 years ago

    more people go on the other gamecube games witch have not got any one in it

  17. creul.lollypop.bba 5 years ago

    i am stuck on the bit when you go back to forsaken fortress and after you defeat phantom ganon and then these wee things that chase after you and make a funny noise and they chase you to a bit you have to jump well i have tried and tried but i just cant get across it

  18. Just Unregistered 5 years ago

    Hey there, could anyone help me with the last tri force shard?...im guessing its on the ghost ship but i dont know how to get on there.. cheers all..and yeah its no baby game..its just a fairy game.

  19. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  20. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  21. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  22. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  23. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  24. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  25. Qasim Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you get into the cabana on the private oasis

  26. Just Unregistered 5 years ago

    Hey Qasim, To get into the Cabana you have to go the school teacher and do her a favour, you know those kids called the killer bees, well you talk to them after talking to the teacher, you play hide and seek with them. you have to chase and catch them. then go back to the school teacher and give her your joy pendants, you will need to give her about thirty or something. she then gives you the cabana deed so you can get in.
    she actually gives you the oasis, There are some mad puzzles in there.

  27. Hassan Unregistered 5 years ago

    I need help getting the wallet that holds 5000 ruppies so Tingle can read the Triforce maps.

  28. just Unregistered 5 years ago

    Hey hassan.To get that wallet you need to go to a fairy island, i think its the one north of tingles island. do you have your fairy chart?

  29. Anon Unregistered 5 years ago

    Could somebody please tell me exactly where the stupid shard is around uotset island. Every site says its around the beach but theres nothing indicating that its there. Is there a glitch or am i just completely lost

  30. just Unregistered 5 years ago

    Hey Anon. there is a scroll to get onto the ghostship on that island your talking about but you have to use the hookshot to get up on there. there is a shard on the ghost ship.

  31. *_* Unregistered 5 years ago

    Wheres Tingles Island located?!

  32. im stuck Unregistered 5 years ago

    where do i find the bow and arrow?

  33. Pari:-D Unregistered 5 years ago

    Hello
    :D
    how do u get the bracelet?

  34. Ryan Unregistered 5 years ago

    how do you find the triforce piece which is on the ghost ship

  35. bbj Unregistered 5 years ago

    were is the 8th trforce piece

  36. tyler Unregistered 5 years ago

    i need to know wich locations the triforce pieces are not the maps!

  37. link the pink Unregistered 5 years ago

    how to get the triforce 6 shard?

  38. jeremyruff_08 Unregistered 4 years ago

    wher is the exactly is the ghostship map in the game

  39. link da man Unregistered 4 years ago

    where are the four killer bees

  40. Stefan Unregistered 4 years ago

    where the hell is ivan this sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  41. Stefan Unregistered 4 years ago

    where the hell is ivan this sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  42. 123Fakestreet Unregistered 4 years ago

    Where is the bow and arrow located?

  43. samantha Unregistered 4 years ago

    This game rocks but I am on windfall island and the pirates are there but it is raining and the bombshop is closed can somebody help me and tell me what I am doing wrong?

  44. LordAlucard Unregistered 4 years ago

    You have to go on the side of the shop and look for some weeds to climb on.When oyu climb the weeds you will see a crawl space and I think you'll know what to do next.

  45. joe yo7 Unregistered 4 years ago

    where are the shards located

  46. joe yo7 Unregistered 4 years ago

    the bow and arrow are in the tower of gods

  47. joe yo7 Unregistered 4 years ago

    the killer bees are1.hidden behind a bush2. up a tree roll into it3. behind the tomb stone thing4.behind the bomb shop

  48. DL Unregistered 4 years ago

    hey i was wondering if anyone could tell me what do you take a picture of to give to that one guy that says to take one of something pale and round? ive beat everything thats needed in the game but im stuck on this and a few other little side quests please help...:)

  49. ilvmyk9@aol.com Unregistered 4 years ago

    How do you find the eight shards

  50. ilvmyk9@aol.com Unregistered 4 years ago

    how do find the eight shards

  51. LordAluacrd Unregistered 4 years ago

    The Round and Pale thing is the sun

  52. PrincessZelda Unregistered 4 years ago

    This Zelda game was way to short and I hated the animation.......I can't wait until the Twilight Princess comes out!!! :-)

  53. DL Unregistered 4 years ago

    yea man i cant freaking wait till twilight princess myself ive got a copy reserved jeeze i cant wait

  54. warren h Unregistered 4 years ago

    to get all 4 bottles lissen u get one wen u help the bird thing neer the beginning, u can buy one from a shop boat by rock spire isle, u can get one from a submarine by bomb island, and on wind fall turn it night with song of the passing go to the trampy girl follow her then when she has the rupee sign on her head talk to her.

    thats how u get all 4 bottles

  55. Lordalucard Unregistered 4 years ago

    I have all 4 bottle and all the heat pieces.cant be sure though.O.o

  56. Goron King Unregistered 4 years ago

    the worst desisons nintendo made in the wind waker:

    1. flood hyrule (you dont even get to return it to normal in the end) (my opinion nintendo just was not made for the open sea)
    2. not use link as the hero
    3. kill off the Zoras
    4. remove the gorons from the game (with exception of the 3 merchents) (gorons are the best!!!)
    5. have a story line that requiers side quest to be done before you can move on in the game (dont get me wrong side quest are in all but they should not be requiered to win the main game)
    6. kill off the zelda look (you ask the cartoon feel of the game is stupid)
    7. make the game short (with the crapy graphics they could have made this one of the longest zelda games ever.
    8. make the dungons as easy as hell
    9. use a stupid baton insted of the ocarina (some of those stupid "songs" are hard to remember and you have to play them at the right time so there is no time to think) (this was not a problem for me but is was for some others I know)
    10. Where the hell is epona
    11. they make you sail to every island and it takes to stinken long
    12. to many hiden charts (If they were all bundeled in one big dungon and you did not have to sail to the middle of freakin no where it might not be so bad)

    despit my harsh review I did enjoy playing the game (even though I had to practicly give a walk through of the whole game to everyone I Know)

    (Ocarina of time rulz)

  57. Goron King Unregistered 4 years ago

    sorry for the posting twice

  58. aarron Unregistered 4 years ago

    ddfdrxgrsx

  59. LordAlucard Unregistered 4 years ago

    I think Majoras Mask was better than wind waker and ocarina of time.=P

  60. kevin the master Unregistered 3 years ago

    can some one help me find the last shard inside the ghost ship?

  61. master sw0rd Unregistered 3 years ago

    samantha i could help u on the pirate place go behind the bomdshop and climp up on to that stupid grass thing and u'll see a yellow thing then use crounch in it then u'll see the pirate talking then when there done the nerdy guy will tell u the password then get out of the bombshop then go to the pirate ship then enter the password what the guy said

  62. master sw0rd Unregistered 3 years ago

    WHO KNOW WHERE THE HECK DO U GET THE GHOST SHIP CHART AND GET INSIDE THE STUPID GHOST PIRATE SHIP????

  63. MaStEr sw0rd Unregistered 3 years ago

    tingle island near windfall island just use south west

  64. Chris marde Unregistered 3 years ago

    I dont know where the peices of the triforce are(the 8 shards).Please tell me asap.

  65. monty Unregistered 3 years ago

    where is the Private Oasis island i really need to know like is it a3 or by an island

  66. rdyrtdyd Unregistered 3 years ago

    how do you get on the mother isle?:-/

  67. gamecubedavid Unregistered 3 years ago

    the game was awesome but too short.The best thing you can do to make the game look longer and harder is to search every simple and other complicated secrets and find all the items.Also the hardest part for me was to collect all the statues that you trade with the goron and others and place them into their place.Sorry for my poor english,if i have any mistakes its because im from greece and a big fun of zelda games.

  68. gamecubedavid Unregistered 3 years ago

    answer goes to rdyrtdyd.In order to get on mother island you have to defeat cyclon with your arrows and then he will teach you the ballad of galles which can transport you over some cyclones and one of the cyclons transport you into the mother island.I hope i helped you enough with your problem and greetings to all of the zelda and nintendo funs

  69. dillon Unregistered 3 years ago

    whats the password for the pirateship

  70. ???k.k Unregistered 3 years ago

    Its radom. I ask my friend what password and she got a different one from mine.

  71. kain Unregistered 3 years ago

    how to solve the riddle wats round a pale????

  72. kain Unregistered 3 years ago

    how to solve the riddle wats round a pale????

  73. marty Unregistered 3 years ago

    how am i supposed to find those triforce pieces? when i found tingle all he did was give me some stupid think where yoy need to connect ur game boy advanced, and where do i get the wallet? and where exactly is his island? and isn't the fortress destroyed by now? how can i free him if it is destroyed?

  74. hh Unregistered 3 years ago

    hhh

  75. weee Unregistered 3 years ago

    how do u get on the ghost ship?!

  76. weee Unregistered 3 years ago

    how do u get on the ghost ship?!

  77. weee Unregistered 3 years ago

    where do i get the tri triforce charts interperted?!

  78. weee Unregistered 3 years ago

    what is taking u so long to anser?!

  79. hauskenseth Unregistered 3 years ago

    Who do you take a picture of that's sending mail to a love that doesn't love them back? And when do you do it?

  80. ineedhelp Unregistered 3 years ago

    how do you get the bow and arrow in the wind waker?

  81. T-TrusT Unregistered 3 years ago

    This game has its tricky parts but its bot that good 5 out of 10 is being nice and if your over 15 and playing this game u need to get a new hobby. I mean the only reason i played this game is becuase mybrother wanted me to beat a level

  82. austin Unregistered 3 years ago

    no help at all u losers

  83. hell boy Unregistered 3 years ago

    how do i get the little tree guy out of the cage with the stone i cant lift in front of it.

  84. hell boy Unregistered 3 years ago

    the password for the pirot ship is tresure

  85. link fan Unregistered 3 years ago

    chris zelds wind waker is not overrated and u can explore alot even if u dont visit the tingle tower for the triforce shards doesnt mean ur the worst zelda player ever

  86. link fan Unregistered 3 years ago

    u guys help me on finding the triforce shards and also who ever cant get through the first part of the game, like getting the sail really stinks at games

  87. Bryan1 Unregistered 3 years ago

    How do u get into the ghost ship?

  88. BloodFang Unregistered 3 years ago

    Where do you get THE FIRST bow and arrow...I need it to get past a part in the tower of the gods...

  89. Stalfos Killer Unregistered 3 years ago

    Goron King 8/17/2005 4:15:20 PM EST


    the worst desisons nintendo made in the wind waker:

    1. flood hyrule (you dont even get to return it to normal in the end) (my opinion nintendo just was not made for the open sea)
    2. not use link as the hero
    3. kill off the Zoras
    4. remove the gorons from the game (with exception of the 3 merchents) (gorons are the best!!!)
    5. have a story line that requiers side quest to be done before you can move on in the game (dont get me wrong side quest are in all but they should not be requiered to win the main game)
    6. kill off the zelda look (you ask the cartoon feel of the game is stupid)
    7. make the game short (with the crapy graphics they could have made this one of the longest zelda games ever.
    8. make the dungons as easy as hell
    9. use a stupid baton insted of the ocarina (some of those stupid "songs" are hard to remember and you have to play them at the right time so there is no time to think) (this was not a problem for me but is was for some others I know)
    10. Where the hell is epona
    11. they make you sail to every island and it takes to stinken long
    12. to many hiden charts (If they were all bundeled in one big dungon and you did not have to sail to the middle of freakin no where it might not be so bad)

    despit my harsh review I did enjoy playing the game (even though I had to practicly give a walk through of the whole game to everyone I Know)

    (Ocarina of time rulz)

    - I agree with you (expept on the grafics, they are amazing!)
    - Now, agree with me, they made something wrong... We should do so, if we have to cacth too many charts or triforce charts, just use the MAX replay! asdasd, you can get everything and just do what you want... I know, that`s for loosers... so, dont do this, stay at home finding this anoying charts and be a great fat looser!
    Thx

  90. M!()n3Y Unregistered 3 years ago

    ive got 4tri-force pieces but i neeeeeed hbelp getting into the next temples i kow were they are but i just dont know how to get in them sooooo PLEEAAASSSSEEEEEE HEEEELLPPPP MEEEEE!!!! :( loadsa luff nuff luff yeh kodie xxxxx

  91. David Hoffa Unregistered 3 years ago

    I loved this game,the graphics,the plot,the hole thing was great .When I finished I couldent bare it.I had to quit.I rate this game a 10+.All I could do when i finished was to wish the game was longer.I hope there will be a sequill.

  92. l3lacksheep Unregistered 3 years ago

    I still dont know where i get the power braclet this gave me no help when it said on google that this web site had a section on where u get the4 power bracelet ive alrdy gave up on this game b4 so now im looking for starts and this is not a strat :-(

  93. Dionne Unregistered 3 years ago

    I love The Legend of Zelda - The Wind Waker !!
    Young Link = Cute!! :-D

  94. link lover Unregistered 3 years ago

    to get on diomond steppe isle just use your hookshot on the trees

  95. koo Unregistered 3 years ago

    Where do you find the hammer?

  96. thatonekid Unregistered 3 years ago

    a full moon is the perfectly round and pale thing, but it has to be with the DX pictobox

  97. lost Unregistered 2 years ago

    I need serious help here. I have triforce chart 2, but I sail over to Gale Island and search all around the triforce emblem. But I can't find it! I don't see any beam of light or hear any music. Some guides tell me it is just northwest of gale island, but where exactly? Can someone give me a landmark, something? Anything? Is something just wrong with my game?

  98. lost Unregistered 2 years ago

    I need serious help here. I have triforce chart 2, but I sail over to Gale Island and search all around the triforce emblem. But I can't find it! I don't see any beam of light or hear any music. Some guides tell me it is just northwest of gale island, but where exactly? Can someone give me a landmark, something? Anything? Is something just wrong with my game?

  99. lost Unregistered 2 years ago

    I need serious help here. I have triforce chart 2, but I sail over to Gale Island and search all around the triforce emblem. But I can't find it! I don't see any beam of light or hear any music. Some guides tell me it is just northwest of gale island, but where exactly? Can someone give me a landmark, something? Anything? Is something just wrong with my game?

  100. Help me' Unregistered 2 years ago

    How do you get into the mother isle?

  101. More comments